NFL Over/Under After a Shootout: 27 Years Tested

NFL teams coming off a game that went 15 or more points over the total went over again only 49.61 percent of the time from 1999 through 2025, across 1,943 graded games. The market raised their next total by about a point, and that was enough. After a big under, the next game went over 51.95 percent, a small edge that has mostly faded since 2020.
NFL teams coming off a shootout don't keep going over. From 1999 through 2025, teams whose last game finished 15 or more points over the closing total went over in their next game 964 times and under 979 times, a 49.61 percent over rate, based on closing lines in nflverse's game data. The market raised their next total by about a point on average, and that was enough. The Best Bet on Sports has built a verified $367,520+ in profit across all sportsbooks over more than twenty years, and recency bias like this is one of the first things we check before a trend gets near our card.
Week 10 gave us an 86-point game. Dallas and San Francisco combined for 86 points against a closing total of 55.5. Tennessee and Jacksonville put up 63 on a 45.5 total. And now Tennessee visits Dallas on Sunday, with both teams coming straight off a shootout.
You'll hear it all week: "Both of these defenses just gave up 40. Hammer the over." Or the other version: "Everyone's on the over now, so the value is on the under." We tested both against 27 years of results.
Do NFL Teams Go Over Again After a High-Scoring Game?
No more often than any other team. Here's every team's next game, grouped by how its previous game finished against the total, for the 1999 through 2025 regular seasons. The previous game had to be in the same season.
| Previous game vs total | Team-games | Next game O-U | Over rate | Next total vs last total |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Over by 15+ | 1,969 | 964-979 | 49.61% | +1.06 |
| Over by 7.5 to 14 | 1,863 | 911-917 | 49.84% | +0.49 |
| Over by 0.5 to 7 | 2,532 | 1,228-1,267 | 49.22% | +0.31 |
| Under by 0.5 to 7 | 2,740 | 1,311-1,397 | 48.41% | -0.39 |
| Under by 7.5 to 14 | 2,171 | 1,072-1,065 | 50.16% | -0.75 |
| Under by 15+ | 1,610 | 825-763 | 51.95% | -1.22 |
All NFL regular-season games in that span went over 49.49 percent of the time. Every bucket after an over sits right on top of that baseline.
The last column is the part most bettors miss. After a big over, the team's next total was about a point higher than its last one. After a big under, it was about 1.2 points lower. The market adjusts. The shootout is already in the next number.
Do Both Teams Coming Off a Shootout Matter?
This is the situation Tennessee and Dallas are in. Here's what happened when both teams' previous games fell into the same group:
| Both teams' previous game | Games | O-U | Over rate | Avg total | Avg points |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Both over by 10+ | 346 | 179-163 | 52.34% | 44.98 | 46.42 |
| Both over by 7.5+ | 560 | 284-266 | 51.64% | 45.12 | 46.45 |
| Both went over | 1,563 | 778-762 | 50.52% | 44.71 | 45.64 |
| Both went under | 1,639 | 831-791 | 51.23% | 42.48 | 43.60 |
| Both under by 7.5+ | 537 | 276-254 | 52.08% | 42.24 | 43.15 |
| Both under by 10+ | 302 | 162-138 | 54.00% | 42.41 | 43.61 |
Two shootout teams meeting went over 52.34 percent of the time. That's a little better than average, but it's 342 graded games, and a result that far from 50 percent would show up by chance about 42 percent of the time. It's noise.
The more interesting number is on the other end. When both teams were coming off a game that went under by 10 or more, the next game went over 54.00 percent of the time. When either team was coming off an under by 15 or more, it went over 52.27 percent across 1,498 graded games. Chance would produce that about 8 percent of the time. It's the one result here with a little weight behind it, and it points the opposite way from what most people expect.
Do Over and Under Streaks Keep Going?
No. Streaks are where recency bias is strongest, so we checked those too:
| Streak (team view) | O-U next game | Over rate |
|---|---|---|
| Team went over 3 straight | 642-656 | 49.46% |
| Team went under 3 straight | 674-708 | 48.77% |
| Streak (game view) | O-U | Over rate |
|---|---|---|
| Both teams over 2 straight | 190-190 | 50.00% |
| Both teams under 2 straight | 180-205 | 46.75% |
An over streak doesn't predict another over. The under streak is a mild exception. Two teams that had each gone under twice in a row went under again 53.25 percent of the time. That runs against the big-under result above, which is a good reminder that small slices of the same data can point in different directions.
Has the Big-Under Bounce Held Up?
Not really. Here it is by era:
| Seasons | Over rate after big over (15+) | Over rate after big under (15+) | Baseline |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1999-2009 | 51.30% | 50.00% | 49.81% |
| 2010-2019 | 47.65% | 54.63% | 49.94% |
| 2020-2025 | 49.66% | 50.60% | 49.43% |
Almost all of the big-under bounce came from 2010 through 2019. Since 2020, it's 168-164, basically even. In 2026 through Week 10, teams after a big over are 25-25 on the over, and teams after a big under are 17-17.
So the honest answer is that the totals market prices last week's game correctly. It did for a decade where it slightly overreacted to unders, and it's back to pricing it correctly now.
Which Week 11 Games Fit These Spots?
Here are the Week 11 games involving teams coming off the biggest overs and unders of Week 10, using early lookahead totals from nflverse's schedule data. These numbers will move.
| Game | Week 11 total | Last game vs total |
|---|---|---|
| Tennessee at Dallas | 54.5 | TEN +17.5, DAL +30.5 |
| Indianapolis at Houston (Thu) | 44.5 | HOU +10.5, IND +8.5 |
| Baltimore at Carolina | 43.5 | CAR -11.5, BAL +3.5 |
| New Orleans at Chicago | 48.5 | NO -11.5, CHI +3.5 (Week 9) |
Tennessee at Dallas is the only true "both off a shootout" game on the slate, and it already carries a 54.5 total, the highest on the Week 11 board. Dallas's own total dropped a point from 55.5 to 54.5 even after the 86-point game, because the opponent changed. That's the point: the number reflects who's playing, not what happened last Sunday.
How Can You Tell If a Pick Service Is Selling Recency Bias?
"They just gave up 45, take the over" is one of the most common pitches in football betting. When you're comparing services that sell NFL expert picks, here's how to judge it.
A good service will tell you what the market already did with last week's result. If the total went up a point, the shootout is priced in, and the pick needs a reason that isn't last week's score. It'll tell you how the trend has done recently, not just over 27 years, because this one has faded. And it'll show you why the last game went over. A defense that gave up three long touchdowns on blown coverages is different from one that faced 14 extra possessions because of turnovers.
That last part is handicapping. Final scores aren't. If you're deciding whether a sports handicapping service is worth paying for at all, that page covers what to look for, and our list of football handicappers explains how we're different.
At The Best Bet on Sports, we bet live, and we've been limited on all six major U.S. sportsbooks (FanDuel, DraftKings, Caesars, BetMGM, Fanatics and ESPN BET) for winning too much at it. Our NFL picks page has the weekly card, and our football betting picks page explains how we approach a slate. For another test of a popular totals angle, see our study of NFL referee over/under trends.
What This Study Doesn't Cover
This study uses closing totals and final scores from nflverse's game data for every NFL regular-season game from 1999 through 2025, plus 2026 through Week 10. A team's "previous game" is its last game in the same season, so Week 1 games are left out, and a game after a bye is matched to the team's last game before the bye. Pushes are excluded from records. Other books may have closed a half point different, and a few results near the number could grade differently. Week 11 totals are early lookahead numbers from the same source. The chance figures assume each game is a 50-50 coin flip against the total.
Get Tonight's Live Picks
Want live in-game NFL calls, including the totals spots where a pregame number built on last week's shootout doesn't match how this game is being played, sent to your phone during the game?
The Best Bet on Sports is the only live betting handicapping service limited on all six major U.S. sportsbooks (FanDuel, DraftKings, Caesars, BetMGM, Fanatics, ESPN BET) for winning too much during in-game action. Verified profit: $367,520+. Live calls go out through Email and Discord during games, and every bet in the $10,000 to $100,000 challenge is posted as it happens.
ā Join The Best Bet on Sports community ā newsletter, live stream and Discord ā Try a free live pick first ā reserve your spot for tonight's pick
Frequently Asked Questions
Do NFL teams go over the total after a high-scoring game?
No more often than usual. From 1999 through 2025, teams whose previous game went 15 or more points over the closing total went over in their next game 49.61 percent of the time, going 964-979. All regular-season games went over 49.49 percent.
How much does the NFL total move after a shootout?
About a point. Teams coming off a game that went 15 or more points over saw their next total rise an average of 1.06 points from their previous total. After a game that went 15 or more under, the next total fell 1.22 points.
Should you bet the over when both NFL teams are coming off shootouts?
Not blindly. When both teams' previous games went over by 10 or more points, the game went over 52.34 percent of the time across 342 graded games from 1999 through 2025. A result that size shows up by chance about 42 percent of the time.
Do NFL teams go over after a low-scoring game?
Slightly more often. Teams coming off a game that went 15 or more points under went over next time 51.95 percent of the time from 1999 through 2025. Since 2020, though, it's 168-164, basically even.
Do NFL over/under streaks continue?
No. Teams that went over three straight games went over in the next one 49.46 percent of the time from 1999 through 2025. Teams that went under three straight went over 48.77 percent of the time.
What NFL games in Week 11 of 2026 feature teams off a shootout?
Tennessee at Dallas on Sunday, November 22. Dallas's last game went 30.5 points over and Tennessee's went 17.5 over. The early lookahead total in nflverse's schedule data is 54.5. Houston, at home against Indianapolis on Thursday, is also coming off a game that went 10.5 over.
Is betting against recency bias in NFL totals profitable?
Not as a system. The totals market raises or lowers the next number by about a point after an extreme result, and since 2020 teams coming off big overs and big unders have both landed close to 50 percent. The edge comes from knowing why last week's game went over or under.
The Best Bet on Sports Ā· 1.5M followers on TikTok
Sports Betting TikTok is the live betting account behind The Best Bet on Sports, covering NFL, NCAAF, NBA, NCAAB, MLB and WNBA markets in real time. The account has been limited on all six major U.S. sportsbooks ā FanDuel, DraftKings, Caesars, BetMGM, Fanatics and ESPN BET ā for winning on live betting, with $367,520 in verified profit since 2005. View full profile ā
Past results do not guarantee future performance. Must be 21 or older to wager.
Related Articles
NFL Double-Digit Favorites Against the Spread: 27 Years Tested
NFL Christmas Day Against the Spread: Favorites Are 9-19-1
NFL Total Turnovers Prop: How Often Over 2.5 Really Hits
NFL Total Touchdowns Prop: How Many TDs a Game Really Has
NFL Opening-Drive Touchdown Prop: How Often It Really Hits
NFL New-Stadium Bump: Seven Openings, No Home Edge
Get real live betting picks
From $39.95/mo Ā· Cancel anytime Ā· Email + Discord delivery
ā Get The Picks
Choose your package
Tap any tier below to select Ā· Subscribe in one tap
š Tap any package to select it
ā You're selecting
25 Units Ā· $99.95/month
25 unit picks per month. Sweet spot for most bettors ā plenty of action without going all-in.
- ā25 live betting selections/month
- āEmail + Discord delivery
- āAll sports (NFL, NCAAF, NBA, NCAAB, MLB)
- āMix of 1, 2, 3, 5-unit rated plays
- āCancel anytime
Secure PayPal Ā· Cancel anytime Ā· No hidden fees Ā· 21+ Ā· +$367K verified
+$367,520 verified Ā· Limited on 6 sportsbooks Ā· 20 years documented Ā· See Proof
Join Our Newsletter
Get free expert sports picks and analysis delivered weekly.