4 NFL Starters Gone in 6 Days: Only 1 Moved the Odds

Drake Maye, Aidan Hutchinson, Puka Nacua and Daniel Jones were all lost Nov. 15-20. The market priced only one at full value. Our betting-impact ranking.
Between November 15 and November 20, the NFL lost four high-profile starters: Patriots QB Drake Maye (fractured right fibula), Lions edge rusher Aidan Hutchinson (torn ACL), Rams WR Puka Nacua (MCL surgery) and Colts QB Daniel Jones (released). Only one moved the betting market sharply. DraftKings pushed New England from +2400 to +10000 to win the Super Bowl after Maye went down. Detroit's line barely moved, and the Rams' title price got shorter.
It was the worst six-day run of player news this season, and it happened in a week when three of the four teams involved had either a bye or a game that had already been priced. That makes it an unusually clean test of a question bettors argue about every Sunday: how much is one player actually worth to a point spread or a futures price?
The answer this week was blunt. The market charged one of these losses at full price and shrugged at the other three. Below is the ranking, from the loss that cost the most to the one that may not have cost anything at all.
The Six-Day Damage Report
| Rank | Player | Team (record) | What happened | Market reaction |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Drake Maye, QB | Patriots (5-5) | Fractured right fibula, Nov. 15 in Munich | Super Bowl odds +2400 to +10000 (DraftKings) |
| 2 | Aidan Hutchinson, EDGE | Lions (7-2) | Torn ACL, Nov. 15, out for season | Week 11 line vs. Bucs held at DET -6 |
| 3 | Puka Nacua, WR | Rams (6-4) | MCL surgery, likely out for season | Super Bowl odds improved, +1300 to +1200 (Fox Sports) |
| 4 | Daniel Jones, QB | Colts (3-8) | Released Nov. 20 after a 26-3 loss | Colts were already 12.5-point underdogs |
Records as reported November 16-20. Super Bowl prices via Bleacher Nation (DraftKings) and Fox Sports. Week 11 lines via Sports Betting Dime's odds-movement tracker and Fox Sports (bet365), November 20. Prices move, so check a live book before betting.
1. Drake Maye, Patriots: The Only Loss Priced at Full Value
The sequence in Munich took less than a drive. On New England's opening possession of the November 15 game against Detroit, Hutchinson sacked Maye. Maye left the game, and the Patriots lost 35-10. Early reports feared an ankle fracture. ESPN's Adam Schefter and Mike Reiss then reported a fractured right fibula that will not require surgery, but that is expected to keep him out deep into the regular season, if he returns this year at all.
The market's response was immediate. According to Bleacher Nation, DraftKings moved the Patriots from +2400 to +10000 to win the Super Bowl. That is an implied probability drop from roughly 4% to about 1%. ESPN's Football Power Index landed in the same place, giving New England a 0.9% chance to reach the Super Bowl and a 36.5% chance to make the playoffs, according to NESN's reporting of ESPN analyst Seth Walder's numbers.
Three things made this the most expensive loss on the board:
- Position. A starting quarterback is the single largest input in any spread model, and the Patriots' backup plan is Tommy DeVito, per ESPN's reporting.
- Timing. New England is 5-5, has lost two straight and three of four, and sits in a crowded AFC wild-card race. There is no cushion to absorb a month of replacement-level play.
- Stacking. Receiver A.J. Brown is also expected to miss multiple weeks with a hamstring injury, according to Yahoo Sports. The Patriots lost their quarterback and their top target in the same week.
Head coach Mike Vrabel has ruled Maye out for Week 12, and New England is on a Week 11 bye. That bye means the first spread that fully prices a DeVito-led offense has not been posted yet. When it is, it will show the real gap between the two quarterbacks, separate from the futures move.
2. Aidan Hutchinson, Lions: A Real Loss the Spread Ignored
Hutchinson's season ended on the same play that started Maye's absence. He tore the ACL in his right knee while celebrating that first-quarter sack, according to multiple reports, and ESPN's sources raised concern about additional damage, particularly to the meniscus. Head coach Dan Campbell confirmed the tear. It is the second time in three seasons a leg injury has ended Hutchinson's year, as NFL.com noted.
Hutchinson had six sacks this season, tied for second on the team, after a career-high 14.5 a year ago. The Detroit News reported the injury came about two weeks after middle linebacker Jack Campbell suffered a spinal-cord injury, so the Lions' front seven has now lost two core starters in a fortnight.
Here is the strange part. Detroit's Week 11 line against Tampa Bay opened at Lions -6 and, as of Thursday's Sports Betting Dime snapshot, was still -6. Only the juice moved, from -110 to -113. The total dipped from 46.5 to 45.5. Fox Sports' bet365 listing had Lions -6.5. The opening number was posted after the Munich game, so some of the injury was baked in from the start, but nobody has bet the line off -6 since.
Two reasons explain the muted reaction:
- Pass rushers move totals and live lines more than pregame spreads. The industry's general rule of thumb puts even elite non-quarterbacks at about a point or less of spread value. A torn ACL to a star edge rusher hurts the Lions' ceiling in January more than it hurts a mid-November spread.
- The other quarterback is the bigger variable. Baker Mayfield missed Wednesday's practice with foot and right-thumb injuries and was limited Thursday. Bucs coach Todd Bowles said he is "trending in the right direction." If Mayfield plays, the market sees a fair -6. If he sits, the spread will likely grow, with or without Hutchinson.
Fox Sports' most recent Super Bowl board lists Detroit at +1800. For futures bettors, the honest read is this: the Lions are 7-2 and still a top NFC team, but a defense without its two best front-seven players is a bigger concern in a playoff game than in Week 11.
3. Puka Nacua, Rams: The Market Had Already Moved On
Nacua's injury is not new. He sprained his MCL and PCL and suffered turf toe on the Rams' final offensive snap of a November 8 win over Washington, and he went on injured reserve on November 12. On Friday, Sean McVay said Nacua had surgery Tuesday to repair the MCL and will be out "a couple of months." NBC Sports and several outlets reported that the procedure likely ends his 2026 season.
There is also an off-field complication. The NFL suspended Nacua three games under its personal conduct policy on November 19, and he is eligible to return December 14. The suspension runs while he is on injured reserve, so in practice the surgery is what decides his timeline.
The surprise is the price. Los Angeles routed Arizona 34-6 in its first full game without him, its fourth straight win, and Fox Sports reported the Rams' Super Bowl odds improved from +1300 to +1200. Friday's surgery news confirmed a long absence that bettors had already assumed.
That does not mean Nacua is worth nothing. He had 70 catches for 715 yards and four touchdowns in seven games, after leading the league with 129 receptions and 1,715 yards last season. CBS Sports also lists Davante Adams as sidelined. Over a full playoff run, losing your two best receivers matters. But the Rams are 6-4 and 2.5 games behind the 8-1 49ers in the NFC West, so their futures price depends far more on how a wild-card team travels in January than on any single receiver.
4. Daniel Jones, Colts: Released, and Nearly Free to Lose
The Colts released Jones on Friday, the morning after a 26-3 loss in Houston on Thursday Night Football. Jones completed 12 of 27 passes for 144 yards with one interception and no touchdowns. Shane Steichen announced the move. The Big Lead reported that Jones had thrown a league-leading 13 interceptions in the first year of a two-year, $88 million contract.
Anthony Richardson Sr., the former No. 4 overall pick, takes over as the starter, beginning with the Giants' visit to Indianapolis in Week 12. His two relief appearances this year both came in blowout losses, and on Thursday he missed his first two throws before Houston ran out the clock.
From a betting standpoint, the Colts' collapse had already been priced. Houston closed as a 12.5-point home favorite in a division game, covered easily, and the total of 43.5 stayed under. At 3-8, Indianapolis is out of the futures conversation. The only open question is whether Richardson's arm talent produces more volatility than Jones did, which tends to make a team a better live-betting target and a worse pregame one.
What the Ranking Tells Bettors
This week was a clean lesson in how the market values players. Four takeaways follow.
Quarterbacks are priced, and almost everyone else is discounted. The only loss that drew a big move was the quarterback on a team still in contention. A star pass rusher on a 7-2 team barely moved the spread. That is not always correct, but it is consistent, and that consistency is where the edge comes from.
Watch the first spread after a bye. New England's first post-injury line comes in Week 12. Look-ahead numbers set before the injury will reprice, and the first move is usually the biggest. Our study of NFL quarterbacks returning from injury against the spread covers the other side of this, when the starter comes back.
Defensive injuries show up in games, not in spreads. If you think Detroit's pass rush will fade without Hutchinson, the better place to act may be in-game, when a Lions defense fails to pressure a quarterback on third down and the live total has not caught up. We made the same case for the AFC race in our AFC No. 1 seed breakdown.
Futures overreact less than you think. The Rams' price got shorter while Nacua sat. Futures follow results and schedule strength first. For the full title picture, see our Super Bowl contenders ranking.
The Best Bet on Sports has been limited at six major U.S. sportsbooks for winning on live action, with a verified $367,520+ in profit since 2005. Follow the $10,000-to-$100,000 challenge on our results page, and join the newsletter, live stream and Discord on our join page. Every Week 11 and Week 12 side is on our NFL picks hub and the NFL picks against the spread page, the full football picks card covers both the NFL and college slates, and Saturday's games are on the college football picks page. If you are comparing sports handicappers for the stretch run, start with the record. More analysis is on the blog.
---
Frequently Asked Questions
How long will Drake Maye be out?
Maye has a fractured right fibula that will not require surgery, according to ESPN's Adam Schefter and Mike Reiss. The injury is expected to sideline him deep into the regular season, and he may not return in 2026 at all. Mike Vrabel has ruled him out for Week 12. The Patriots are on a bye in Week 11, so Tommy DeVito is expected to start when New England returns.
How did Drake Maye's injury affect the Patriots' Super Bowl odds?
DraftKings moved New England from +2400 to +10000 to win the Super Bowl, according to Bleacher Nation, a drop in implied probability from about 4% to about 1%. ESPN's Football Power Index gave the Patriots a 0.9% chance to reach the Super Bowl and about a 36.5% chance to make the playoffs after the 35-10 loss to Detroit dropped them to 5-5.
Is Aidan Hutchinson out for the season?
Yes. Hutchinson tore the ACL in his right knee in the first quarter of Detroit's 35-10 win over New England in Munich on November 15, while celebrating a sack of Drake Maye. Dan Campbell confirmed the tear, and ESPN reported concern about additional meniscus damage. He had six sacks this season after a career-high 14.5 in 2025.
Did the Lions' spread change after Hutchinson's injury?
Barely. Detroit's Week 11 line against Tampa Bay opened at -6 after the Munich game and was still -6 on Thursday, with only the price moving from -110 to -113, per Sports Betting Dime. Some books list -6.5. The bigger variable is Baker Mayfield, who was limited in practice with foot and thumb injuries but is trending toward playing.
Is Puka Nacua out for the rest of the 2026 season?
Probably. Sean McVay said Nacua had MCL surgery and will miss "a couple of months," and several outlets reported the procedure likely ends his season. He was also suspended three games by the NFL on November 19 and is eligible to return December 14, but the surgery sets the real timeline. He had 70 catches for 715 yards in seven games.
Why did the Colts release Daniel Jones?
Indianapolis released Jones on November 20, the day after a 26-3 loss at Houston in which he went 12 of 27 for 144 yards and an interception. The Big Lead reported he had a league-leading 13 interceptions in the first year of a two-year, $88 million deal. The Colts are 3-8, and Anthony Richardson Sr. will start against the Giants in Week 12.
Which NFL injuries move betting lines the most?
Starting quarterbacks, by a wide margin. Non-quarterback stars, even elite pass rushers and receivers, usually move a pregame spread by a point or less. This week showed it clearly: Maye's injury cut New England's Super Bowl price by about three-quarters, while Hutchinson's torn ACL left Detroit's spread unchanged and Nacua's absence came alongside a shorter Rams title price.
The Best Bet on Sports Ā· 1.5M followers on TikTok
Sports Betting TikTok is the live betting account behind The Best Bet on Sports, covering NFL, NCAAF, NBA, NCAAB, MLB and WNBA markets in real time. The account has been limited on all six major U.S. sportsbooks ā FanDuel, DraftKings, Caesars, BetMGM, Fanatics and ESPN BET ā for winning on live betting, with $367,520 in verified profit since 2005. View full profile ā
Past results do not guarantee future performance. Must be 21 or older to wager.
Related Articles
Super Bowl Odds After Week 8: Contenders Ranked
NFL Trade Deadline 2026: Sellers, Buyers, Ranked
NFL's 4-0 Teams: Why Odds Still Favor the 2-2 Rams
Tua Tagovailoa's Oblique: The Injury a Spread Can't Price
AFC No. 1 Seed Odds: 5 Teams, 1 Bye
NFL Trade Deadline Grades: Every Deal's Odds Impact
Get real live betting picks
From $39.95/mo Ā· Cancel anytime Ā· Email + Discord delivery
ā Get The Picks
Choose your package
Tap any tier below to select Ā· Subscribe in one tap
š Tap any package to select it
ā You're selecting
25 Units Ā· $99.95/month
25 unit picks per month. Sweet spot for most bettors ā plenty of action without going all-in.
- ā25 live betting selections/month
- āEmail + Discord delivery
- āAll sports (NFL, NCAAF, NBA, NCAAB, MLB)
- āMix of 1, 2, 3, 5-unit rated plays
- āCancel anytime
Secure PayPal Ā· Cancel anytime Ā· No hidden fees Ā· 21+ Ā· +$367K verified
+$367,520 verified Ā· Limited on 6 sportsbooks Ā· 20 years documented Ā· See Proof
Join Our Newsletter
Get free expert sports picks and analysis delivered weekly.